Thursday, March 13, 2008
B&B 6-7
I had never heard of the six trait model before reading this chapter but it seems like a really good way for students to learn what makes a good paper. Chapter 7 also had some good ideas for hands on activities that are non-tradtional and fun for the students as well as instructive, such as making a brocure of their hometown or analyzing greeting cards. On Wednesday in my class at Hickman everyone brought in song lyrics to analyze using critical approaches, such as feminist, Marxist, historical, etc. and the activity was a huge success. It was fun both for us as teachers and for the students and a good change of pace, and also prepared them to apply those critical approaches to more literary works, which they will be doing in the near future. I always enjoyed activities like this when I was in high school and hope I am creative and forward thinking enough to come up with fun activities like this when I teach. Another nice thing about the six trait model is it provides is it provides a uniform way for grading student's work, so that everyone understands why they got the grade they got and eliminates the issue of fairness or inequality. It would be nice, even, if all English teachers could get on board using the same rubric for writing workshop so students are not confused from class to class. It gives students all the specific elements they need for a good paper and all they have to do is apply them.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3 comments:
The think I like about six traits is that it gives everyone a common "language" to use when discussing a piece of writing. When conferencing with a student, then, the teacher doesn't have to spend vital conferencing time explaining/defining terms being used to discuss the paper.
Eric, I agree. I think the six trait model is great... if all English teachers use it we would all be on the same page. I do not think it is good if kids think they can slack off in a class and then in the next they have to work super hard and are not prepared. We are supposed to teach kids how to write and if we are all not following the same assessment plan students might not come prepared from one year to the next. I also LOVE the song idea. Not only can it help kids explore different theories in literature, but it is also a great way for them to express themselves... which they like to do!
Like you Eric, I too hope that I will remember some of the creative activities I've picked up on over the years. I definitely want to incorporate as many creative opportunities as I can in my class. My only question, how many is too many? And will my school allow them. I hope they don't make me prove myself for my first ten years as a teacher until they finally let me include my creative ideas in my classroom because I might become a teacher I don't want to be. The song idea is so clutch, I'm using an activity that involves analyzing a song in my lesson that I'm teaching at Hickman so wish me luck....
Post a Comment